Archive topic

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

Fabrications, mistaken identifications and media-driven stories, examined through the evidence that created, spread or corrected them.

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media16 entries
The Cock Lane Ghost: Knocks, Crowds and an Enlightenment Hoax feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Cock Lane Ghost: Knocks, Crowds and an Enlightenment Hoax

The Cock Lane Ghost became a public test of spirit claims, murder accusations and experimental controls. Contemporary investigators ultimately exposed deliberate production of the knocks.

hoaxpublicCock Lane, Smithfield, London; representative street pin1760–1762; public investigation in February 1762
Mary Toft: The Rabbit Births That Fooled Georgian Doctors feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

Mary Toft: The Rabbit Births That Fooled Georgian Doctors

Mary Toft’s rabbit-birth claims were a documented medical hoax. The case reveals unequal power, weak observation and the speed with which professional authority can magnify a spectacle.

hoaxpublicGodalming, Surrey; representative town pinSeptember–December 1726
The Mad Gasser of Mattoon: Odours, Fear and a Wartime Town feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Mad Gasser of Mattoon: Odours, Fear and a Wartime Town

The Mad Gasser episode combined sincere symptoms, ordinary odours, rumour and alarming press coverage. A coordinated chemical assailant was never established.

explainedpublicMattoon, Illinois; representative town pinLate August–September 1944
Cattle Mutilations: What the Investigations Actually Found feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

Cattle Mutilations: What the Investigations Actually Found

Cattle-mutilation claims became a national mystery through alarming field appearances and uneven investigation. Forensic work explains many features without proving a single cause for every report.

disputedpublicDulce, New Mexico; representative pin for a distributed United States case clusterMajor reporting wave, 1973–1980
The Max Headroom Broadcast Intrusion: Ninety Seconds Unsolved feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Max Headroom Broadcast Intrusion: Ninety Seconds Unsolved

The 22 November 1987 intrusions interrupted WGN briefly and WTTW for about ninety seconds. An attacker probably overpowered microwave programme links; the FCC inquiry found no culprit.

uncertainpublicChicago, Illinois; representative city pin22 November 1987
The Amityville Horror: A Haunting Built for Print feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Amityville Horror: A Haunting Built for Print

Claims made after the Lutz family’s 1975 stay became a bestselling book and film franchise. The murders in the house were real; evidence for the subsequent haunting is not reliable.

disputedpublicAmityville, Long Island; representative village pinDecember 1975–January 1976
The Black Knight Satellite: How Separate Stories Became One Object feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Black Knight Satellite: How Separate Stories Became One Object

The Black Knight is a composite legend assembled from unrelated radio experiments, Cold War tracking stories and STS-88 photographs of lost thermal insulation.

explainedpublicKennedy Space Center; representative STS-88 mission anchorLegend assembled across 1899–1998 and later internet retellings
The Great Moon Hoax and the Machinery of Wonder feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Great Moon Hoax and the Machinery of Wonder

In 1835, newspaper readers met moon forests, lunar animals and winged people in a celebrated lesson about media, science and appetite.

hoaxpublicNew YorkAugust 1835
Piltdown Man: The Fossil That Flattered an Expectation feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

Piltdown Man: The Fossil That Flattered an Expectation

Piltdown Man fooled parts of the scientific world for decades because forged evidence appeared to fit a story people were ready to hear.

hoaxpublicPiltdown, SussexAnnounced 1912; exposed 1953
The Surgeon’s Photograph and the Shape of a Monster feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Surgeon’s Photograph and the Shape of a Monster

The famous Loch Ness image became a visual shorthand for lake monsters, then a lesson in scale, cropping and media appetite.

hoaxpublicLoch Ness, Scotland1934 photograph; hoax account publicised later
The Cottingley Fairies: Paper Wings, Cameras and Belief feature image

Hoaxes, Misidentifications & Media

The Cottingley Fairies: Paper Wings, Cameras and Belief

Two Yorkshire cousins, a camera and a set of fairy photographs became one of the most instructive image hoaxes of the twentieth century.

hoaxpublicCottingley, West Yorkshire1917-1920; admissions in the 1980s